null Skip to main content

Peanut Butter Cup Cookie Pie

(4 reviews) Write a Review
2.00 LBS
Calculated at Checkout

file types are bmp, gif, jpg, jpeg, jpe, jif, jfif, jfi, png, wbmp, xbm, tiff

file types are bmp, gif, jpg, jpeg, jpe, jif, jfif, jfi, png, wbmp, xbm, tiff

Adding to cart… The item has been added

What is a Cookie Pie?
Barbara’s Cookie Pies are a cookie-in-a-cookie. It all starts with premium-quality butter cookie dough made from a family recipe passed down through the generations. This buttery–rich cookie dough (a treat by itself) forms the bottom layer of each cookie pie. Then each is garnished with delectable toppings made from quality fresh ingredients such as fresh fruit preserves, marshmallow, creamy peanut butter, coconut, apple, buttercreams, caramel, almond, real chocolate and more – for a palate-pleasing treat. It’s the evolution of the cookie into something bigger and better. 

Peanut Butter Cup: Think Reese's Peanut Butter Cup...only bigger and better. This sensational Cookie Pie combines peanut butter filling, and dark chocolate on top of a rich butter cookie for an off-the-charts taste experience. Simply special, this is our noble laureate of Cookie Pies.

Butter Cookie Crust:Fresh creamery butter, sugar, unbleached flour, real vanilla, whole eggs
Topping: Whipped peanut butter, confectioners sugar, real vanilla , real semi-sweet chocolate

Product Weight : 19.6 oz., Product Size: 7 inches

Standard: Each Cookie Pie comes shrink-wrapped with a cardboard serving disk packaged in a white corrugated shipping box.
Gift-Wrapped: Each gift-wrapped Cookie Pie is shrink-wrapped on a cake disk, then beautifully cartoned with ribbon of your choice, bow and personalized note card. The gift-wrapped Cookie Pie nests in colored shred inside a white corrugated shipping box.

A custom label or hangtag can be added to either option with any message or graphic you want. Please call Barbara at 732-995-0497 or if you have any questions.


4 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Thank you!!!!

    Posted by Adrienne C on Aug 14th 2020

    Barbara’s peanut butter cookie cake was amazing! I ordered it for my son’s 19th b day and she made it so special for him! He actually liked this more than his actual birthday gift because it was custom made for him. Thank you and you have a customer for life!

  • 5
    Great Pies!

    Posted by Anthony G. on Jul 2nd 2019

    Ordered a cookie pie for a family birthday and it was fantastic. The owner is very nice and you can tell that the cookie pies are all freshly baked per order

  • 5
    Quality every time, all the time!

    Posted by Unknown on Jun 19th 2018

    Personalized your sweet tooth gifts is one of the special benefits of sending Barbara’s Cookie Pies to friends, family, and customers!

  • 5

    Posted by Danielle Barcelou on Jan 30th 2018

    Brought this to a family gathering. Everyone loved it.

about barbara